Could be Mahi Kantha which is a district to the north of Baroda and seems to encompass Ahmednagar. There is a Mahi River. Many thanks to Sylvia Murphy for finding the place in her Imperial Gazeteer Atlas.
Surname Name Relationship to Head of Family Condition Sex Age Rank, Profession or Occupation Where born 516 ETHERIDGE Alfred Thos. - Unmarried M 25 Lieut't Bombay Army England, London 517 WALLACE Robert Head Married M 39 Capt. Bombay Army East Indies